What It Means To Be An Effective Representative; Why Leadership and Community are Essential

What follows are some thoughts I put together for Vic Harris that reflects ideas discussed during his campaign. –MBock

I am seeking the Democratic primary nomination to be elected representative for the 40th Ohio House District. As one representative out of a group of ninety nine, some representatives are more effective than others. I’ve been analyzing what it means to be an effective representative.

I find it interesting that the those in control of the government in Ohio decided to give an annual windfall of $460 million to the top 1% of incomes in the state — incomes that average $650,000 — and that these same representatives, because of decreased state revenues, are now diminishing and cutting important state programs that benefit average Ohioans. This is interesting because I am amazed at how those controlling the government advance such indefensible actions. You would think that in a democracy such a government would not stand.

What seems obvious is that our system of government that we are rightly proud of — our representative democracy — is simply not working as it should. If our system was working as it should, our government would not advance indefensible actions, our government policies would reflect the consensus of the vast majority, not the selfish interests of the few, our government policies would work to promote the common good.

So, when I reflect on what it means to be an “effective” representative, it seems to me the central question that needs to be asked is, “effective” at what? It seems the majority of the political class first of all seek to be “effective” at getting elected. And reelected.

In my thinking, an “effective” representative, is a person who, first of all, focuses his or her dedication on promoting the general good. As a core belief, this definition of “effectiveness” is huge. Can you imagine the impact that a political party could have that could become driven and controlled by this central core belief ? The name of that Party, of course, should be, The Democratic Party.

The general good is what advantages the vast majority of citizens, so it makes sense that a representative of the citizens would make promoting the general good a central aim of his or her leadership. If our democracy were working as it should we would be empowered to choose representatives who would be effective in promoting the common good. One impediment to our democracy, as it turns out, is the undemocratic practices of political parties.

For our democracy to flourish, we need leadership. I’ve given a lot of thought to this — what leadership is, how leadership is developed. A effective representative of the people should be an effective leader for the people. A leader is one who raises up everyone around him and who inspires and empowers others. An effective leader raises up other leaders.

But, here is the problem, I’m convinced that leadership is a function of an effective community. Without community, leadership is void. And, the truth is, community is lacking.

Right now, there is not a 40th Ohio House District community as such. There is Trotwood, Northridge, Riverside, Brookville and part of Dayton that is contained in the 40th District. But these together do not make a 40th District community. And, a more profound problem is that there seems, other little community anywhere. How many people who have a Trotwood mailing address really participate in a Trotwood community? How many with a Northridge address participate in a Northridge community? Hillary said, “It takes a village,” but it seems that the village itself, the community of people who know and care about each other, has largely disappeared.

The model for effective community that is often cited is the New England Town Hall Meetings. These meetings occur in small towns, and all interested citizens in the town have a voice. In such a communities, effective leadership is nurtured and potential leaders have many opportunities within the community to prove their capacity for leadership.

The thought I want to develop is this: I believe it is possible to create effective community here in the 40th Ohio House District. All the pieces are in place ready for us to create an authentic cyber community.

In the 40th District, there are 104 precincts. I believe with the right invitation, that on average, at least two or three persons from each precinct would come forward to volunteer to be a regular participant in a 40th District cyber community. I believe that there are many citizens who would welcome the opportunity to meaningfully participate, if given an invitation.

I think here in Dayton we can become known for making a new breakthrough in innovation — a breakthrough that effectively uses the technology of the day to vitalize local democracy. So I’m thinking what such a web-site for such a community might look like, how it might function.

So here are my conclusions. To be an effective representative means to be effective at defining and promoting the general good. An effective representative is an effective leader, and leadership is always a function of community. So, in order for me to be an effective leader, I plan to invest my time and skills in creating an authentic 40th District community. If I am to effectively “represent” the people of my district, I need to be part of an authentic community that reflects the whole district.

My thinking is that although we are not a New England town, we can create a Town Hall feel and a Town Hall reality by creating an organized group of individuals, each dedicated to communicating and respecting each other, dedicated to learning how to function as a community. I think such a group should be internet based.

The 40th House District must be united as a community. Even twenty years ago this would have been much more difficult to accomplish than it is today. Our opportunity is to use the power of the tools of our age to help solve the challenges facing our democracy

Posted in M Bock | Leave a comment

The Empire Strikes Back: The Ohio Democratic Party Spends Big Bucks on Lieberman and Winburn

I received a professionally produced full color handbill in the mail yesterday praising Debbie Lieberman and urging me to “Re-elect Debbie Lieberman on March 4th.” In large print is the statement, “Endorsed by the Montgomery County Democratic Party.” On the front of the handbill are several nice pictures of Debbie, one by herself, one with her and Commissioners Dan Foley and Judy Dodge and the statement, “Team Montgomery County, Working Together for a better tomorrow.”

There is no mention on the handbill about the fact that Debbie a few weeks ago was arrested for drunk driving and that the video of her embarrassing drunken encounter with the police was widely shown on local TV.

The handbill has a boxed statement printed on it, “Paid for by the Ohio Democratic Party, Chris Redfern, Chairman” Producing these handbills and mailing them to Democrats throughout the county, I’m guessing, must have cost the state Democratic Party something close to $30,000.

Debbie has no Republican challenger in the fall general election. She does have a Democratic opponent in the March 4 Democratic Primary, a man named Mark Anthony Newberry. I don’t know much about him, but, I’m voting for Newberry.

In the 40th Ohio House District the state Democratic Party is distributing a full color, great looking handbill urging 40th District Democrats to vote for Roland Winburn. The headlines say that Roland is the “Endorsed Democrat,” and that “Democrats Endorse Roland Winburn for State Representative.” It features pictures of State Senator Tom Roberts and State Representative Fred Strahorn along with statements of endorsements. Again the handbill includes the boxed statement, “Paid for by the Ohio Democratic Party, Chris Redfern, Chairman.” Producing these handbills and mailing them to 40th District Democrats had to cost something like $9,000.

Roland’s competitor is Victor Harris, the non-endorsed candidate, and Victor has been advancing a good campaign — sending two mailers to all 40th District Democrats, TV and radio ads, and door to door visits with Democrats throughout the District. A huge boost to Vic has been the unprecedented strong support of the Dayton Daily News which in several prominent editorials has urged 40th District Democrats to support Victor. This post explains.

The Empire — the Democratic Machine — is striking back. This outpouring of money from the State Democratic Party to support Debbie Lieberman is outrageous. But even more maddening is the fact that the State Party is spending money in the 40th District to promote one viable Democratic candidate over another viable Democratic candidate. The Party is corrupting the primary system and is showing itself to be corrupt — focused on promoting its own insider interests.

This $50,000, or so, that the state machine is pouring into Montgomery County for Winburn and Lieberman is wasted money. This money should be used to help elect Democrats in marginal Districts.

Word is that the Democratic Party also is organizing workers to hand out pro-Winburn literature at 100 ft from each polling place in the 40th District. The Party will pay each poll campaigner a wage for the day. I don’t know how much. This action is simply outrageous.

Victor is organizing poll campaigners to match the Party machine’s poll campaigning efforts. He needs help to make this effort successful. If you have any time on March 4 to campaign at a polling place in the 40th District — to talk with incoming voters and give out Victor’s literature — send me an e-mail ASAP at mbock@att.net. Or, leave me a message at 298-8703. I am going door to door this afternoon and I will respond to any e-mails or messages this evening. We really need a grassroots uprising to help Victor in this election effort.

Posted in Local/Metro, M Bock | 20 Comments

DDN Gives Harris Two New Strong Endorsements; Democratic Insiders Attend Winburn’s Fund Raiser

Democratic Chair Mark Owens must be gritting his teeth. Today’s Dayton Daily News, on its editorial page, gives Victor Harris — the candidate not endorsed by the Montgomery County Democrats — two new and very strong newspaper endorsements. These endorsements are in addition to the newspaper’s strong Feb 8 endorsement of Harris. The editorial headline states, “Few Candidates Do the Basics Before Running, Victor Harris is Notable Exception”

These new endorsements for Harris come in the wake of a big fund raiser for Victor’s opponent, Roland Winburn, attended by many local Democratic Party insiders. Wednesday, about 100 attended $50 plate fund raiser dinner for Winburn. The event featured Chinese food, and by all appearance was a big success. To get 100 people out on a Wednesday evening to pay $50 each is a big achievement for any campaign. It looks like it owes its success to the big support of the local Democratic Party. A partial list of those who attended are: Mark Owens, Fred Strahorn, Debbie Lieberman, Karl Keith, Tom Roberts, and Nan Whaley. I don’t know whether Clayton Luckey, the unopposed Democrat who represents the neighboring 39th District, attended.

The DDN editorial describes Winburn as “a nice man and party regular.” Winburn was officially endorsed by the Montgomery County Democratic Party at their meeting December 14. As a Central Committee member, at the time, I objected to the Party’s action and wrote about their endorsement here.

The DDN says, “Winburn waited his turn, but seems to have spent considerably less time thinking about what he might actually do to represent the district.” On the other hand, the newspaper praises Harris: “Good government is no accident. It starts with candidates willing to move beyond political chatter and actually prepare themselves for the job. Voters should reward Mr. Harris for having done just that.”

On the same page, Martin Gottlieb, in a column entitled, “On Candidates New And Old,” slams several candidates, including County Commissioner Debbie Lieberman, and gives Victor this praise, “Then there’s Vic Harris, the young-though-retired military officer who wants to succeed Fred Strahorn. He has a background that must make anybody take note.”

These endorsement articles today emphasize and add to the newspaper’s Feb. 8 editorial, “Our recommendation: Harris offers Democrats much needed life in 40th District.” With today’s additional editorials, the newspaper is emphasizing it strong support for a local primary candidate to a degree and manner that to me seems unprecedented. Mark Owens and the Montgomery County Democratic Party leadership, who endorsed Roland Winburn rather than Vic Haris, must be seething at the newspaper’s action.

The more I think about it, really, the more I am perturbed that the local Democratic Party would take official action to actively endorse and support one viable candidate over another viable candidate in a primary election. In their endorsement practices, I think the leadership of the Montgomery County Democratic Party is sorely out of touch with the thinking and wishes of the vast majority of county Democrats.

This local expression of blatant party insider favoritism would never be tolerated on a national level. Can you imagine the outrage, if, early on, the National Democratic Party had officially endorsed one of the Democratic Presidential candidates and had discouraged other viable candidates from running? Insider favoritism makes no sense whether at the local or national level.

Gottlieb, in his column, notes that, regardless that County Commissioner Debbie Lieberman recently had a well publicized drunk driving arrest, she has little to fear, because she has no opponent in the general election. Gottlieb reports the corrupt collusion between Democrats and the Republicans that gave Debbie and other candidates a free pass by making an agreement between the parties that certain candidates would have no opponents in the general election. (DaytonOS reported this arrangement, Montgomery County Dems/GOP Conspire to Limit Democracy, on December 31.) Lieberman, the wife of former Montgomery County Chair Dennis Lieberman, has no Republican opponent for the general election and, in return, the Republicans in the positions of County Coroner and sheriff, have no Democratic opponents. It seems obvious that local politics, as controlled by the local Montgomery County Republican and Democratic Parties, needs a lot of reform.

The newspaper articles today, in praising Vic Harris, take a deserved slap at the Montgomery County Democratic Party. Mark Owens and the entire local Democratic Party leadership have a lot of explaining to do. The election of Victor Harris, I’m hoping, will be an impetus for needed reform in the Democrats’ county organization.

Posted in Local/Metro, M Bock | 1 Comment